Showing posts with label trade. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trade. Show all posts

Saturday, February 11, 2017

Trump, Libertarians, and Trade



Introduction

From my post on the positive aspects of Trump for those who favor libertarianism and decentralization – certainly when compared with the alternatives – I offer one of the several positive items:

He questions trade deals.  I understand the dilemma that this presents for libertarians and free market types, but we can’t have it both ways: we know that the so-called “free trade” foisted on us isn’t free trade, it is government management crony trade.

The Challenge

Matt Welch at Reason has since come out with a post precisely on this dilemma:

Libertarians have long been sensitive to the paradox near the heart of international tariff-reduction projects of the past seven decades. On one hand, increasingly free global trade flows have irrefutably played an outsized role in lifting a billion people out of poverty in the last quarter-century alone. On the other, multilateral trade agreements by definition create institutions, such as the World Trade Organization (WTO), beyond the direct reach of sovereign democratic polities.

A reasonably good statement; unfortunately, not leaving well enough alone….

Those of us who have accepted that trade-off have found ourselves for decades having to both defend and try to improve from within the "Washington consensus" on liberalizing tariffs. But now that that consensus has been repudiated at the polls all over the Western world, it's time for the other side of that intra-libertarian argument to make its free trade case within an imperfect vessel.

Why must those on “the other side of that intra-libertarian argument…make its free trade case within an imperfect vessel”?  Commonly referred to as the Hegelian dialectic, why must libertarians (or anyone else) limit their arguments to a pre-determined set of boundaries?

So the ball's in your court, Thomas Massie, Daniel Hannan, Ron Paul, and all the other libertarians who have argued for years that free trade agreements aren't the same thing as free trade.

Welch is asking the impossible: play within these non-libertarian boundaries and come up with a libertarian solution.  There is no libertarian solution within those boundaries: free trade agreements are not only not the same thing as free trade; they are not even free trade agreements.

The Rebuttal

Why didn’t Welch ask for Murray Rothbard to offer his arguments as to why (managed, but most certainly not) free trade agreements are not free trade?  I will ask Murray:

I’m puzzled. I’d like to know why so many free-marketeers, so many free-market think-tanks and pundits, are not simply pro-Nafta, but are fervently, frantically, almost hysterically pro-Nafta.

To quote the king: is a puzzlement.

Look, I can understand, though not agree with, mild approval. An old libertarian friend of mine, for example, told me that he was mildly pro-Nafta but not really interested in the entire topic. That seems sensible.

I can understand mild approval as well; I also do not agree.

There is no libertarian answer within these pre-established boundaries.  The only libertarian answer is to get government out of the trade business; this option isn’t offered.  So on what libertarian basis would I disagree?

World Government…

…as offered by Welch (cited above but also here for reference):

Sunday, January 29, 2017

Who Will Pay That 20 Percent Tariff?



Trump has floated the idea of a 20 percent tariff on goods imported from Mexico in order to pay for the wall.  This is Trump’s way of fulfilling a campaign statement (one dare not call them promises, given the track record of virtually every elected official on earth): Trump will build a wall and Mexico will pay for it.

One bad idea begets another.  The wall is the first bad idea: there have been numerous “walls” built along the southern border of the United States; none have apparently been successful towards the intended purpose.  Why try another?  There are other ways to patrol a frontier; better yet, place all property in private hands and let’s be done with this issue.

The tariff is a second bad idea.  Why punish Americans via an added sales tax?

But just how, precisely, will Americans be punished?  And will the tariff be borne only by American consumers?  I suggest not.  I will use an example of an import of which I know something about: beer.

Dos Equis – a fine Mexican beer.  Let’s call the price today $6 for a six pack.  Will I now have to pay $7.20?  Only if one believes the producer is in charge of the price.  But of course, in a market it is the consumer that is in charge.

Most beer drinkers can enjoy multiple varieties of beer.  In place of Dos Equis, it is easy enough to buy a nice Belgian import – say Leffe – a beer not subject to this new tariff.  Is this American who buys Leffe instead of Do Equis subject to the tariff?  Certainly, he may not be able to enjoy his preferred choice of beer, but he still has many fine beers to choose from; Mexico isn’t the only beer-producing country in the world.

What happens next?  Will all non-Mexican producers of beer raise prices by 20% to take advantage of this gift from Trump?  I suppose it is possible, but given the level of competition in the beer market, not likely.  Of course, for the handful of beer connoisseurs who model themselves after “the most interesting man in the world,” nothing but Dos Equis will do.  For these consumers, the 20% increase will come out of their wallet….or will it?

What is more likely is that sales of Dos Equis will fall due to this tariff.  The burden will end up on the shoulders of the producer in Mexico.  Will the producer cut price to maintain volume or will he maintain price and see a reduced volume?  This is the producer’s choice and in either choice the producer will pay.

In other words, Trump is more right than a simple analysis suggests.

I know my example is a simple one – there are much more complicated situations – the electronics and automotive industries have complicated supply chains between and amongst Mexico, the United States, Canada, Europe and Asia, for example.  Exactly how these play out, under any scheme floated by Trump, is anyone’s guess.  But I stick to a subject I know – beer!

Am I suggesting that I support the tariff because the other guy will pay?  Never.  Reduced trade is always a bad idea; any government action that restricts trade is a bad idea (in other words, every government action is a bad idea because every government action restricts trade).  It lowers the standard of living for everyone – not only the two involved in the trade, but for everyone else (except for the thief and his friends).  Money stolen for one purpose is money not spent on the value-driven choice by the owner on a different purpose.

But my main point regards who will pay.  And economics teaches us that the answer is not so simple; there are always secondary effects to be considered.

Saturday, April 13, 2013

Settlement



This post is the result of a dialogue at The Daily Bell.  It was prompted by an editorial written by Hugo Salinas Price, entitled “Of Bubbles and Bitcoins.”  The pertinent comment in the editorial, and my feedback to it, as follows:

HSP: In the exchange of any given merchandise for gold (or silver), neither of the parties to the interchange ends up owing the other party. There has been "settlement."

BM: There is settlement when one individual trades a coconut for a dollar bill. Neither owes the other anything more.

I did not intend to write a post about this, but the subsequent dialogue influenced my thinking. 

I guess I am confused about the term “settlement.”  Please bear with me….

I give you a coconut in exchange for your giving me an apple.  We agree that neither of us owes the other anything more.  This certainly seems like a settled trade to me.

Now, I give you a coconut in exchange for your giving me a gram of gold.  We agree that neither of us owes the other anything more.  This also certainly seems like a settled trade to me.

Let’s try another.  I give you a coconut in exchange for your giving me a plain white sheet of paper.  We agree that neither of us owes the other anything more.  Is there something about this trade that remains in the not-settled arena?  It seems to me this trade is also settled.

I will now take one more step: I give you a coconut in exchange for your giving me a piece of paper with a pretty painting on it – perhaps a lovely seascape.  We agree that neither of us owes the other anything more.  Not settled?  No, I think still settled.

Last step.  I give you a coconut in exchange for your giving me a piece of paper with a picture of a dead politician on the front and a picture of some monument to the state on the back.   We agree that neither of us owes the other anything more. 

It is argued, at least by HSP and a few feed-backers at DB, that this trade is not settled.  But why not?  Neither party owes the other anything more.

The closest answer comes from mava:

When you sell a coconut for a dollar, you receive no settlement, because the dollar is only a promise, not a good in itself.

But somehow, it is suggested that gold is different in this regard.  Why?  Is not gold only a “promise” in the sense that the term is used in this sentence?  After all, there is no guarantee regarding the future value or desirability of my gold.  Am I not dependent on someone accepting the gold in the future for something I desire?

But wait (I hear it coming), gold is a good – it is a commodity, useful for purposes other than money.  Yes, I understand this.  But what is a piece of paper with a painting on it, other than a commodity, useful for purposes other than money?  Is the argument that a painting of a seascape fits this definition, but a painting of a dead politician does not?  I hope not.

When you sell a coconut for gold, you have settled the transaction, because you have already received something in exchange, that does not depend on whether your buyer has funds (bounced checks), or, whether the system is in good standing (such as is a big question with the dollar and the bitcoin), or whether your bank happens to be on a particula island (Cyprus).

Each of these apparent problems is equally an issue with gold: a bounced check – equally a problem if you accept a certificate for gold as opposed to the coin; system in good standing – what does this even mean?  A system is functioning or it isn’t – the fiat system is functioning today as the primary means of trade for (my guess) 99% of global transactions.  This isn’t enough?; bad bank – what about a bad vault?

But I greatly deviate from my original point.  When I make a trade of something for something, there is settlement.  That I choose to accept a piece of paper with a picture of a dead politician on the front and a picture of some monument to the state on the back is my own problem, isn’t it? 

The person who gave me that piece of paper owes me nothing more.  What more is there to settle?  Any good I accept that is not for consumption purposes comes with the same risk – that someone will want it when I am ready to consume at some point in the future.

To avoid more strawmen – yes, I believe gold stands the test of time better than pieces of papers with a dead politician’s picture on it.  But this doesn’t change the fact of settlement when that paper is used in trade. 

What is good for the micro is good for the macro.  Only macro-economic-policy-planning-economists believe otherwise.

Saturday, July 28, 2012

The Entrepreneur


Essentials of Economics, by Faustino Ballvé

In Chapter 3, Faustino Ballvé discusses the role of the entrepreneur:

We have seen that the market is the pivot around which the whole of economic life revolves.  We can say just as well that the market revolves around the entrepreneur.

Ballvé offers a simple definition for entrepreneur:

Strictly speaking, the entrepreneur is anyone who goes to the market to sell or anyone who goes to the market to buy, not for his own consumption, but to resell what he has bought….The entrepreneur aims at making a profit….

This buying and onward selling function can take many forms – for example: buying a good in one location with an eye toward selling the same good in a different location; buying a good and improving it before resale; buying a good and holding it until more favorable market conditions emerge.

In a statement worthy of Ayn Rand, Ballvé sees the entrepreneur as a hero:

Production, around which all economic life revolves, is, then, the great adventure of mankind: it is the struggle with tomorrow, the struggle with the unknown.  The champion, the hero, and frequently the victim in this struggle is the entrepreneur.  He undertakes some enterprise in quest of profit.  But in order to obtain it, he is obligated to satisfy the consumer…the consumer never loses.  The entrepreneur, on the other hand, can see all his hopes of profits transformed into a loss he alone must bear: the profit that the consumers (the general public) made is theirs to keep, while the entrepreneur is ruined.

A trade requires two participants – often referred to as a buyer and a seller (but in reality both are at the same time buying and selling).  In the free market, a trade results in two winners, as each participant prefers what he is buying to what he is selling.  I want the candy bar while the shopkeeper wants my dollar – after the transaction, each of us feels wealthier…else we would not have traded!

For the consumer, the trade ends in a win and his satisfaction is therefore assured: he has eaten the candy bar at a price he deemed appropriate.  However, for the shopkeeper – while the single trade was certainly beneficial – he must continually asses market conditions and make proper estimations regarding all factors of the business.  If he fails at this, he will eventually lose.  However, each and every one of the consumers of candy bars remains, as he was at the time of the trade, a winner.  Thus, Ballvé rightly points out that the profit made by the consumer is his to keep, while the entrepreneur alone bears the risk of miscalculation.

The entrepreneur must make many calculations when planning and executing his business.  What are costs today and what will be costs in the future as I produce?  What is the demand for the goods today and in the future?  How will this demand affect pricing?  Where is the competition and what actions are they taking or might they take in response to my efforts?  How much capital is necessary in the fulfillment of the business plan?  All of the calculations are calculations of probabilities – none of them can be exact because all of them regard expectations of conditions in the future.

In the meantime, countless numbers of consumers have had wants and needs satisfied.  For the entrepreneur, the calculations continue.  For him, his reward is profit if he properly calculates and loss if he does not. 

What a harrowed existence!  Ballvé asks if all of this can be avoided by political means.  He suggests that he will answer this more fully in subsequent chapters, however here he makes a very simple yet profound statement on the matter:

We shall concern ourselves later with the proposals that have been advanced and even tried with this object [of somehow using political means to avoid or minimize these risks] in view, whether by way of a change in the whole economic system or by way of corrective measures designed to overcome the alleged “weaknesses of free enterprise.”  But here we can already anticipate this much: What the entrepreneur cannot foresee, nobody can foresee, because, as we have said, science is impotent in the face of the unknown.

No one can know more than the entrepreneur.  No one else is risking his capital or the capital specifically entrusted to him.  No other means can be devised to bring to market the items most desired by consumers – that is to say, the general public.

There is no scientific formula for profits that is available to someone else not the entrepreneur- such a formula is not even available to the entrepreneur!  He is making a guess – hopefully a well-educated one, but a guess nonetheless; a guess based on probabilities.

Can the state make a better guess? Actors not in the market, not investing their own capital or capital voluntarily given for investment?  Regulators?

The free market is a market where consumers – the general public – rule.  It is a market where entrepreneurs take the risks.  The consumers always end up as winners in the trade; the entrepreneurs win only if they make good calculations of probabilities.

Instead of the free market, where the general public is the object to be served, much of the world is offered a political market.  In this market, it is the producer that is supported – supported by various means of regulation and restriction of competition.  Supported by subsidies designed to prevent loss or minimize the negative impact of poor calculation. 

Every one of these regulations and subsidies serves to diminish the role of the consumer.  Yet it is the consumer that ultimately is the best regulator of the market.  The consumer decides which producers are properly satisfying wants and needs.  The best form of democracy is the democracy brought on by the wallet of the consumer acting in a free market.

In less than ten pages, Ballvé makes plain the most simple and important of truths: leave the market free and the general public will find the greatest amount of its wants and needs fulfilled.

And the cornerstone and hero of this simple truth is the entrepreneur.

Thursday, February 9, 2012

The Fallacy of Prosperity Through a Devalued Currency (again)

http://mises.org/daily/5904/Will-Currency-Devaluation-Fix-the-Eurozone


I have come to conclude that one of the main reasons that devaluing the currency is advocated is to boost reported earnings for multi-nationals in their home country, therefore increasing the stock price and therefor increasing the wealth of the management. Of course, the politicians will latch onto any story that allows them to spend without discipline.

Bear with me....

It is clear that in order to consume one must produce. Inherently, it is also true that in order to produce one must consume. As no company (or nation) is self-supporting for all materials in production, the materials must be acquired before the finished goods can be sold. With a depreciating currency, once the existing stock of materials is consumed, the new stock of materials must be purchased - at a higher price. Even for commodities produced locally, prices are set for most commodities internationally – again, currency devaluation will increase the cost of these inputs.

For small businesses that sell locally, currency devaluation is devastating, bringing on hardship and potentially bankruptcy. Raw materials must be purchased at a higher price, yet passing along the increase to consumers is not assured.

But for the larger multi-nationals, this is not such an issue. Most large multi-nationals are not classified as such merely because they sell internationally. Most of them also produce internationally. In other words, the devaluation of the local (home) currency means little to these firms when they are producing and selling in dozens of different countries around the world – with production and sales (along with the capital structure) reasonably aligned to minimize the impacts of currency fluctuations.

In the meantime, back to reported earnings. The large multi-nationals, reasonably protected from the negative ramifications to their cost structure of the devaluated home currency due to the international diversification of their production, now gain the benefit of reporting higher revenue and earnings in the home market due to the devaluation of the home currency. Higher earning, higher share price, bigger bonuses. Like magic.

I conclude that the devalued currency – in addition to destroying the wealth of those who have saved in such units – ruins local manufacturers to the benefit of multi-nationals, while at the same time further benefitting multi-nationals via falsely inflated reported revenue and earnings.