Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts

Sunday, January 29, 2017

Who Will Pay That 20 Percent Tariff?



Trump has floated the idea of a 20 percent tariff on goods imported from Mexico in order to pay for the wall.  This is Trump’s way of fulfilling a campaign statement (one dare not call them promises, given the track record of virtually every elected official on earth): Trump will build a wall and Mexico will pay for it.

One bad idea begets another.  The wall is the first bad idea: there have been numerous “walls” built along the southern border of the United States; none have apparently been successful towards the intended purpose.  Why try another?  There are other ways to patrol a frontier; better yet, place all property in private hands and let’s be done with this issue.

The tariff is a second bad idea.  Why punish Americans via an added sales tax?

But just how, precisely, will Americans be punished?  And will the tariff be borne only by American consumers?  I suggest not.  I will use an example of an import of which I know something about: beer.

Dos Equis – a fine Mexican beer.  Let’s call the price today $6 for a six pack.  Will I now have to pay $7.20?  Only if one believes the producer is in charge of the price.  But of course, in a market it is the consumer that is in charge.

Most beer drinkers can enjoy multiple varieties of beer.  In place of Dos Equis, it is easy enough to buy a nice Belgian import – say Leffe – a beer not subject to this new tariff.  Is this American who buys Leffe instead of Do Equis subject to the tariff?  Certainly, he may not be able to enjoy his preferred choice of beer, but he still has many fine beers to choose from; Mexico isn’t the only beer-producing country in the world.

What happens next?  Will all non-Mexican producers of beer raise prices by 20% to take advantage of this gift from Trump?  I suppose it is possible, but given the level of competition in the beer market, not likely.  Of course, for the handful of beer connoisseurs who model themselves after “the most interesting man in the world,” nothing but Dos Equis will do.  For these consumers, the 20% increase will come out of their wallet….or will it?

What is more likely is that sales of Dos Equis will fall due to this tariff.  The burden will end up on the shoulders of the producer in Mexico.  Will the producer cut price to maintain volume or will he maintain price and see a reduced volume?  This is the producer’s choice and in either choice the producer will pay.

In other words, Trump is more right than a simple analysis suggests.

I know my example is a simple one – there are much more complicated situations – the electronics and automotive industries have complicated supply chains between and amongst Mexico, the United States, Canada, Europe and Asia, for example.  Exactly how these play out, under any scheme floated by Trump, is anyone’s guess.  But I stick to a subject I know – beer!

Am I suggesting that I support the tariff because the other guy will pay?  Never.  Reduced trade is always a bad idea; any government action that restricts trade is a bad idea (in other words, every government action is a bad idea because every government action restricts trade).  It lowers the standard of living for everyone – not only the two involved in the trade, but for everyone else (except for the thief and his friends).  Money stolen for one purpose is money not spent on the value-driven choice by the owner on a different purpose.

But my main point regards who will pay.  And economics teaches us that the answer is not so simple; there are always secondary effects to be considered.

Sunday, September 11, 2016

The Wisdom of Science



Scientists are among the most intelligent people on the planet.  Of course, this does not always make them among the wisest.  But today I offer an example that exemplifies the highest standards of both intelligence and wisdom.

Background

In biology/ecology, parasitism is a non-mutual symbiotic relationship between species, where one species, the parasite, benefits at the expense of the other, the host.

Unlike predators, parasites typically do not kill their host, are generally much smaller than their host, and will often live in or on their host for an extended period.

Parasites reduce host biological fitness by general or specialized pathology, such as parasitic castration and impairment of secondary sex characteristics, to the modification of host behavior. Parasites increase their own fitness by exploiting hosts for resources necessary for their survival, e.g. food, water, heat, habitat, and transmission.

The Discovery

Scientists like Barack Obama so much that they named a parasite after him….World, meet Baracktrema obamai, a deadly turtle pathogen named in honor of our current president.

Scientists and Social Awareness

Believe it or not, it's supposed to be a compliment.

To a scientist, maybe.

Saturday, July 30, 2016

Government Money, Taxes, and War




One key source of income for Louis the German was the collection of tribute – for example, collected from the Danes and various Slavic people.  I find this of little noteworthy interest in and of itself; what is noteworthy is the amount – and what that amount represented:

…Louis could demand some 335 pounds of silver annually from the Slavs and the Danes….Of course, frequent rebellions made it likely that Louis often received only half the owed tribute in a given year.  Nevertheless, the estimate suggests an annual income of some 170 pounds of silver.

Call it $55,000 at today’s price of silver (I am not going to get into pure silver per ounce, troy or otherwise, etc.).

To put the sum in perspective, this amount was enough wealth for the king to reward sixty-eight young noblemen with a complete set of military equipment – a horse, coat of armor, helmet, sword, shield, and spear – every year.

This is about $800 per young nobleman.

I can think of a dozen points that must be examined before I feel I fully understand the meaning of this calculation; I do not intend to examine any of these points.  Instead, I offer two observations:

First, the total sum collected from the entirety of Louis’ non-Saxon tributes is $55,000 in today’s value of silver.  That’s it.

Second, the fighting men of Louis’ time required only $800 worth of equipment to turn them into the most destructive fighting force of Europe at the time.

Times have certainly changed, on both points.

Friday, November 13, 2015

The 5000-Year-Old Archive of Free Traders



The 5,000-year-old Kültepe tablets:

The kiln tablets, considered the earliest written documentation of life in Anatolia, were unearthed during archaeological excavations on the Kültepe-Kaniş-Karum mound in the Central Anatolian province of Kayseri.

Was this the documentation of kings and conquerors, the glories of an ancient warlord?

“The Kültepe tablets are completely owned by the private sector, private individuals. The content of the tablets is 99 percent commercial. They are not official state documents; they are the archive of free traders. In this term, they are the earliest private sector documents. Therefore, the tablets feature the feelings of traders at that time. Thanks to these tablets, we can get information about the socio-cultural structure of people who lived 5,000 years ago. It’s not just shopping; we can see what they went through in their daily life. It is not possible to get such information in the state archives,” said [Professor Fikri] KulakoÄŸlu, [Ankara University Archaeology Department].

Five thousand years ago there was a trading outpost in Central Anatolia, but of what importance are a few camel traders who left behind a few notes?

Kulakoğlu said the Kültepe Tablets were registered by UNESCO because they were the biggest cuneiform tablets in the history of mankind and that they were special in terms of their number and content.

“…biggest…special in terms of their number….”  This was no small trading outpost.  What is this Kültepe?

Kültepe (Turkish: Ash Hill) is an archaeological site located in Kayseri Province in Turkey. The nearest modern city to Kültepe is Kayseri, about 20 km southwest.  It consists of a tell, the actual Kültepe, and a lower town where an Assyrian settlement was found. Its name in Assyrian texts from the 20th century BC was KaneÅ¡ (spoken: Kah nesh), the later Hittites mostly called it NeÅ¡a, occasionally Anisa.

Kaneš, inhabited continuously from the Chalcolithic period to Roman times, flourished as an important Hattic, Hittite and Hurrian city, which contained a colonised large merchant quarter (kârum) of the Old Assyrian Empire from ca. 21st to 18th centuries BC. This kârum appears to have served as "the administrative and distribution centre of the entire Assyrian colony network in Anatolia."

To date, over 20,000 cuneiform tablets have been recovered from the site.

Over twenty-thousand – that sounds like a lot.

The quarter of the city that most interests historians is the Kârum Kaneš, "merchant-colony city of Kaneš" in Assyrian. During the Bronze Age in this region, the Kârum was a portion of the city that was set aside by local officials for the early Assyrian merchants to use without paying taxes, as long as the goods remained inside the kârum.

It was a free trade zone without taxes and apparently, in this free trade zone, life was thriving – over 20,000 tablets, for goodness sake.

Thursday, July 16, 2015

The Gospel According to Francis



I think I need not provide a link or other evidence for the current Pope’s socialist (if not Marxist) leanings and his corresponding wishes for salvation of the poor by the state.  Yet, for ye of little faith in this mosquito, I offer a couple of snippets:

I ask God to give us more politicians capable of sincere and effective dialogue aimed at healing the deepest roots – and not simply the appearances – of the evils in our world!

It must be reiterated that “the more fortunate should renounce some of their rights so as to place their goods more generously at the service of others”.

We can no longer trust in the unseen forces and the invisible hand of the market.

Growth in justice requires more than economic growth, while presupposing such growth: it requires decisions, programmes, mechanisms and processes specifically geared to a better distribution of income, the creation of sources of employment and an integral promotion of the poor which goes beyond a simple welfare mentality.

With that out of the way…I have searched for sources in the Bible that might support these views.  I found passages that were close, but not quite right.  But then I stumbled across a translation I had never seen before.  You have heard of the New International Version (NIV)?  Well, I found the New Comintern-ational Version (NCV).

Following are a few selected comparative verses, with the slightly different translation noted in italics in the NCV.


NIV:  Jesus answered, “If you want to be perfect, go, sell your possessions and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me.”

NCV: Jesus answered, “If you want to be perfect, go, ask your politicians to take your neighbor’s possessions and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me.”


NIV: “But now as for what is inside you—be generous to the poor, and everything will be clean for you.”

NCV: “But now as for what is inside you—ask the Roman guard to force your neighbor to be generous to the poor, and everything will be clean for you.”


NIV: “Sell your possessions and give to the poor.”

NCV: “Take your neighbor’s possessions by popular vote and give to the poor.”

(Please note: the change in the following passage is very subtle – I almost missed it myself.  It should also be noted that Zacchaeus was a wealthy tax collector.)


NIV: But Zacchaeus stood up and said to the Lord, “Look, Lord! Here and now I give half of my possessions to the poor, and if I have cheated anybody out of anything, I will pay back four times the amount.”

NCV: But Zacchaeus stood up and said to the Lord, “Look, Lord! Here and now I give half of his possessions to the poor, and if I have cheated anybody out of anything, he will pay back four times the amount.”


NIV: For Macedonia and Achaia were pleased to make a contribution for the poor among the Lord’s people in Jerusalem.

NCV: For Macedonia and Achaia were pleased to tax the wealthy for the poor among the Lord’s people in Jerusalem.


NIV: As it is written: “They have freely scattered their gifts to the poor; their righteousness endures forever.”

NCV: As it is written: “You must forcefully scattered their wealth to the poor; your righteousness endures forever.”

It is recently reported that the Pope is open to discussing critiques of his criticisms of capitalism.  Given that he has a sound biblical basis for his views from the New Comintern-ational Version of the bible, I suspect these will be very short conversations.