Pages
Monday, April 17, 2017
Investing in Defense Contractors
Monday, April 8, 2013
Thank You, Lew
But today I read a wonderful speech given by Lew Rockwell to the Alabama state convention of Young Americans for Liberty in Auburn, Alabama, on April 6, 2013. In this speech, Lew says in a handful of words all that I could not effectively capture in my grade school attempts.
Following are some of the key passages from Lew's speech regarding the incompatibility of the warfare state and a free society. In addition, I offer my humble commentary.
The Free Market Sans NAP?
Sunday, April 7, 2013
Richard Maybury at The Daily Bell
---------------
-------------
DB: Our bright line begins and ends with free markets …
BM: There are no free markets absent property rights. There are no property rights when it is acceptable to apply deadly aggression against one who has not committed an aggression. Call this a moral argument if you wish. I do view it as moral; I also view it as foundational to free markets.
In any case, as always I thank DB for being so gracious in this forum.
DB reply to above: Maybury is making a recommendation about investments. You seem to be implying that making a purchase is the same as shooting someone. We might well agree that it is morally repugnant to purchase shares in the military industrial complex. It is also morally repugnant to pay taxes that support this infernal system. But to advance an investment argument based on morality is to set up a kind of slippery slope - and that is what we've been trying to explain.
It is better to focus on instruction - and education - than plain "morality" in our view. How can people live better and more fulfilling lives - not more "moral" ones. That is what we try to do here.
Thank you as well for participating; you will perhaps reply further either here or in your own forum. If so, we will read your commentary with interest.
------------
DB, I will write something further on this at my site - I have clogged this thread enough. If I feel it further develops my thoughts, I will post the link in this thread. This may take a day or two.
Friday, February 25, 2011
Richard Maybury: More Thoughts on The Ugly
I have been giving continuing thought on this idea of investing in defense stocks and Maybury's advocacy of same. I would quote something from Rothbard, as it captures well an aspect of my objection:
"This [the availability and use of modern weapons of war as opposed to guns or bows and arrows] is why the old cliché no longer holds that it is not the arms but the will to use them that is significant in judging matters of war and peace. For it is precisely the characteristic of modern weapons that they cannot be used selectively, cannot be used in a libertarian manner.”
The defense contractors of which Maybury speaks do not make handguns. They certainly do not craft feathers for bows. They manufacture weapons whose destructive power cannot be pinpointed accurately to the proper and intended target. We have become inured to the term “collateral damage.” Collateral damage: the killing of innocents and non-combatants.
The weapons Maybury advocates that others invest in, the use of which he tries so sheepishly to defend in the previously linked comments, kill far more innocents than they kill of the guilty. These are not weapons the use of which are morally neutral – just depending on the intent and goodness of the person pulling the trigger, if you will. These weapons, as a regular and expected outcome of their use, as an inherent feature based on the designed capability, kill innocent people.
It is immoral to voluntarily choose to profit from the trafficking in such goods.