Showing posts with label Richard Maybury. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Richard Maybury. Show all posts

Monday, April 17, 2017

Investing in Defense Contractors




My question is, would it be a violation of the NAP or libertarian principles for anti-war libertarians to own stock in companies such as those, either through index funds or by purchasing individual shares in a brokerage account?

Would a libertarian be in violation of the NAP or libertarian principle by working for any of those companies as well, in a capacity not directly related to warfare?

Before specifically getting to Walter’s reply…I have dealt with this topic before, long ago in the very early days of bionic mosquito.  At the time, the point was raised by Richard Maybury at The Daily Bell.  I have a series of posts on this topic of investing in defense contractors, but offer the following as the most relevant:

Richard Maybury: The Ugly: This post expands, in a somewhat crude way given bionic was just a pup at the time, my initial comments on the view that it is not consistent with the NAP for a libertarian to own defense stocks.

Richard Maybury at The Daily Bell: this post furthers the dialogue, including a back-and-forth between bionic and whoever was dealing with feedback at The Daily Bell that day.  This post continues that same dialogue with TDB.

Now, on to Walter’s reply (condensed):

The problem with “owning stock” in a bad company is that you are sort of stuck. Stipulate that it is bad to do so. Well, then, what are you going to do? If you sell your shares, you besmirch the person who purchases them from you. Ditto for giving them away to someone else. How about if you just burn your stock certificates? Then, everyone else’s shares rise in value, with the same result. Stuck, I say.

I see no problem here.  What someone else does with his capital and given his principles is his business.  I am responsible for my own behavior; heaven help me if I am also responsible for the behavior of everyone else.

Yet, I see no answer to the underlying question; for example, what if I don’t own such stock today – therefore none of Walter’s concerns arise?  Is it a violation of the NAP to purchase such stock?

I offer one portion of my earlier posts, linked above; it should be noted, Marbury uses examples of handguns and the like when discussing the ethics of investing in Lockheed Martin or General Dynamics:

Maybury’s position on investing in things that do well in wartime is corrupt.  Maybury advocates profiting from the most hideous outward manifestation of the state: war.  Almost every weapon produced by such investments is one of mass destruction – not able to be aimed solely at the intended target (assuming you even trust the state’s judgment on the intended target, individuals half-way around the world that pose no harm to Americans).

One will say that the weapon cannot be immoral, only the operator.  This is correct for a rifle or bow and arrow.  It can be aimed at the intended target.  Not so for weapons of modern warfare.  All such weapons produce what is sanitarily called “collateral damage.”  These cannot be used in a moral manner.

I go on to cite a Rothbard passage on this same point.

Returning to Walter:

What about working for an evil firm, or, for the government? Well, I was employed by several public universities. One justification is that such schools are not evil per se, since colleges would also exist in the free society.

This is a confusing statement.  Why intersperse teaching at a university with the answer to the question at hand?  In any case, I generally agree with Walter’s conclusion – colleges would exist in a free society.  Further, as colleges are virtually all captured by the state, one who has a calling to be a professor has little choice about the funding nature of his employer; most colleges and universities receive significant state funding – directly and indirectly.

What about working for a governmental institution totally incompatible with liberty, such as the Fed or the CIA. Here, I would say that a libertarian could do so, but, only if he undermined the mission of these institutions, not promoted them.

I cannot disagree with this, although I am personally not very comfortable with this.  What can one say about an Edward Snowden, for example?  That such as he is so rare and that such efforts result in negligible fundamental change suggests how difficult it is to destroy from the inside. 

Otherwise, stay clear – there is nothing compatible with liberty here; such entities would never exist in anything even remotely resembling their current form absent government.

And I say the same for today’s defense contractors; and I conclude that investing in these is a violation of the NAP.

Conclusion

I offer below my responses to the nuanced portions of the original questions.  I realize these are delving deep into the gray areas, so I offer my replies with this caveat:

What about investing in defense contractors through an index fund?  If the index is a broad-based industrial index, I do not see an issue; if it is a focused defense and aerospace index, I think not.

What about taking a non-warfare-related position in a defense contractor?  If it is in the washing machine division, I see no problem.  If it is general corporate G&A or overhead, then I see it as a problem.

Monday, April 8, 2013

Thank You, Lew

Had I only waited one day, I would not have had such a struggle with my post in reply to the Daily Bell regarding my views on the incompatibility of the warfare state and liberty - and therefore my view that profiting from the warfare state was incompatable with developing a free society.

But today I read a wonderful speech given by Lew Rockwell to the Alabama state convention of Young Americans for Liberty in Auburn, Alabama, on April 6, 2013.  In this speech, Lew says in a handful of words all that I could not effectively capture in my grade school attempts.

Following are some of the key passages from Lew's speech regarding the incompatibility of the warfare state and a free society.  In addition, I offer my humble commentary.



LR: First and foremost, Ron is a critic of the warfare state.

BM: It offers the single most extreme transgression against mankind and against the non-aggression principle.

LR: The devastation – in terms of deaths, maimings, displacement, and sheer destruction – appalled every decent human being.

BM: It is a real shame that some can create mind-numbing justifications in order to profit from these actions.

LR: While still in his thirties, Murray Rothbard wrote privately that he was beginning to view war as "the key to the whole libertarian business."

BM: Yet some in the libertarian camp believe that a libertarian society can be developed and maintained while financially supporting and profiting from the war business.

LR: Inspired by Ron, libertarians began to challenge conservatives by reminding them that war, after all, is the ultimate government program.

BM: Yet somehow it is more acceptable for some libertarians to participate in profiting from this government program as compared to other, less deadly, government programs.

LR: [Ron] explained the moral ideas at the root of the libertarian message: nonaggression and freedom.

BM: And absent the root, the tree of liberty will not survive.

LR: I am convinced that historians, whether or not they agree with him, will continue to marvel at Ron Paul for many, many years to come. Libertarians a century from now will be in disbelief at the very notion that such a man actually served in the US Congress of our time.

BM: Amen.



The Free Market Sans NAP?



This is a continuation of this post.

DB: Thank you as well for participating; you will perhaps reply further either here or in your own forum. If so, we will read your commentary with interest.

BM: I can only justify my position based on a moral argument, relying on the non-aggression principle.  I will suggest that DB’s desired libertarian social structure (your “bright line” of free markets, also a moral position) cannot survive absent acceptance of this same non-aggression principle.  Therefore DB cannot draw its bright line where it wishes to draw it without acceptance of the NAP by the vast majority of this free-market oriented society – a moral necessity, I suggest.

There are no truly free markets absent acceptance (and defense) of the NAP by the vast majority of the community: the use of aggression only against those specific individuals who have initiated aggression.  Weapons of mass-destruction (the bulk of what is produced by the modern military-industrial complex) inherently violate this moral principle when used, and every time these are used.  These weapons cannot be used in any manner other than in violation of NAP.  Therefore, I suggest (and agree with Rothbard) that these must be considered in a manner different than weapons such as firearms. 

Unlike many weapons (such as a firearm), it is illogical to suggest that the outcome of a deployed nuclear bomb (to use one of dozens of such weapons of mass destruction produced by this industry) is solely dependent on the choice made by the user – as if good aim and good intent will solve the problem.  The only acceptable libertarian use of aggression (defense against an aggressor) is violated every time the weapon is used.  There is no possible use of the weapon that does not violate NAP.

(The question of development for deterrence is also a moral one, and beyond my scope here – although I will soon read through a book entitled “Nuclear Deterrence, Morality and Realism” to help gain an understanding of this issue.)

DB: But to advance an investment argument based on morality is to set up a kind of slippery slope - and that is what we've been trying to explain….Our bright line begins and ends with free markets …

BM: Drawing the line at free markets is also a moral position, is it not?  It is difficult to consider that this free-market line is brighter than the line that separates alternative views regarding the murder of innocents.  What might this suggest about the investment in goods that, when used as designed, will inherently kill innocents?  A bright line of free markets absent a bright line regarding NAP will not hold, I suggest.  Try maintaining a free-market community that does not accept NAP.

Can you accept NAP yet invest in tools that by their very use violate NAP?  Not a question of how they are used, but every time they are used?  Certainly, it is a moral choice – but what does it say of the one who advocates that this is possible?  “The initiation of force is not legitimate, but investing in weapons that can only be used in such a manner (deadly initiation of force) is acceptable.”  This is illogical and would be laughable if the results weren’t so deadly.

Sunday, April 7, 2013

Richard Maybury at The Daily Bell



Richard Maybury is so wonderfully good on so many subjects, yet he has what I consider one fatal flaw, which taints my view of him whenever I consider his work.  Before that, a few thoughts on other aspects of this interview:

RM: By 1945 it was clear Stalin intended to conquer the world. There was near panic in London and Washington as these governments realized what they'd done by aiding Stalin….[Truman] pledged to help anyone who resisted the Soviet Union.

BM: Maybury assumes the poor saps in charge were idiots when it came to evaluating Stalin in the 1930s.  I suggest that the saps knew what they were doing – setting up communism to be a perpetual enemy for perpetual war.  They wanted Stalin to come out of the war in a strong position, just as they wanted the communists to take over in China after the war.

RM: I don't think [there is a conspiracy to brainwash the population], not at all. It's just government employees teaching today's children a view of life that most government employees were taught when they were students.

BM: Public school teachers teach from the textbooks that are approved by gatekeepers.  They teach to standardized tests that are approved by gatekeepers.  Maybury even (partially) acknowledges this, when he says “The committees don't consciously add lies [to the textbooks]; they just delete facts that are awkward….”

But, of course, they add lies. Read any textbook material on Lincoln, for example.  “He saved the union,” the textbooks proclaim, when in fact he destroyed it.

RM: My 11 Uncle Eric books are what I would say to a young person if I were that individual's uncle.

BM: I have read the two covering the two world wars.  They are truly worthwhile.

RM: the two fundamental laws that make civilization possible are 1) Do all you have agreed to do and 2) Do not encroach on other persons or their property.

BM: a simple yet profound statement.

But now to the ugly. 

RM: My investment model is very simple. Buy things that do well during wartime and currency debasement.

BM: Maybury’s position on investing in things that do well in wartime is corrupt.  Maybury advocates profiting from the most hideous outward manifestation of the state: war.  Almost every weapon produced by such investments is one of mass destruction – not able to be aimed solely at the intended target (assuming you even trust the state’s judgment on the intended target, individuals half-way around the world that pose no harm to Americans).

One will say that the weapon cannot be immoral, only the operator.  This is correct for a rifle or bow and arrow.  It can be aimed at the intended target.  Not so for weapons of modern warfare.  All such weapons produce what is sanitarily called “collateral damage.”  These cannot be used in a moral manner.  See Rothbard:

"This [the availability and use of modern weapons of war as opposed to guns or bows and arrows] is why the old cliché no longer holds that it is not the arms but the will to use them that is significant in judging matters of war and peace. For it is precisely the characteristic of modern weapons that they cannot be used selectively, cannot be used in a libertarian manner.”

I am reminded of this aspect of Maybury every time I read his work or otherwise come across him in this virtual world.  For me, it taints the rest.

---------------



DB: Life, unfortunately, is full of gray tones.

BM: Certainly.  Forgive me if I believe that the indiscriminate taking of countless millions of lives via weapons that cannot be used discriminately (by their very design) is the ultimate expression of the violation of rights that is the state – infinitely exceeding every other state depravation. 

Would I rather be taxed at confiscatory rates, subject to fiat money, controlled about what I eat and drink, spied on without cause, forced to expose every aspect of my financial life; or would I rather the state just kill me and get it over with such that I no longer have to suffer with the other depravations?

The answer should be overwhelmingly obvious.

Life may be full of gray tones, but not for those unfortunate victims of collateral damage on the receiving end of Maybury’s dividend checks.  For these victims, there is no gray tone, only black.  And investing in the producers of this weaponry only supports the murder.  Taxes in support aren’t voluntary, investing is.

As to Rothbard teaching at a public university, I tend to agree with the view that suggests that if an activity would be acceptable in a free society, and the government has for the most part co-opted that activity, then it is acceptable for a libertarian to participate in that activity in this world.  Certainly, being a university professor fits this view.  Even if you disagree, on a scale with NAP at one end and state-sponsored mass murder at the other, being a professor at a public university is pretty close to the benign extreme.

Not bad for Rothbard, given the mud we all swim in.

-------------

 DB: Our bright line begins and ends with free markets …

BM: There are no free markets absent property rights. There are no property rights when it is acceptable to apply deadly aggression against one who has not committed an aggression. Call this a moral argument if you wish. I do view it as moral; I also view it as foundational to free markets.

In any case, as always I thank DB for being so gracious in this forum.


DB reply to above:  Maybury is making a recommendation about investments. You seem to be implying that making a purchase is the same as shooting someone. We might well agree that it is morally repugnant to purchase shares in the military industrial complex. It is also morally repugnant to pay taxes that support this infernal system. But to advance an investment argument based on morality is to set up a kind of slippery slope - and that is what we've been trying to explain.

It is better to focus on instruction - and education - than plain "morality" in our view. How can people live better and more fulfilling lives - not more "moral" ones. That is what we try to do here.

Thank you as well for participating; you will perhaps reply further either here or in your own forum. If so, we will read your commentary with interest.

------------

 DB, I will write something further on this at my site - I have clogged this thread enough. If I feel it further develops my thoughts, I will post the link in this thread. This may take a day or two.

Friday, February 25, 2011

Richard Maybury: More Thoughts on The Ugly

I have been giving continuing thought on this idea of investing in defense stocks and Maybury's advocacy of same. I would quote something from Rothbard, as it captures well an aspect of my objection:

"This [the availability and use of modern weapons of war as opposed to guns or bows and arrows] is why the old cliché no longer holds that it is not the arms but the will to use them that is significant in judging matters of war and peace. For it is precisely the characteristic of modern weapons that they cannot be used selectively, cannot be used in a libertarian manner.”

The defense contractors of which Maybury speaks do not make handguns. They certainly do not craft feathers for bows. They manufacture weapons whose destructive power cannot be pinpointed accurately to the proper and intended target. We have become inured to the term “collateral damage.” Collateral damage: the killing of innocents and non-combatants.

The weapons Maybury advocates that others invest in, the use of which he tries so sheepishly to defend in the previously linked comments, kill far more innocents than they kill of the guilty. These are not weapons the use of which are morally neutral – just depending on the intent and goodness of the person pulling the trigger, if you will. These weapons, as a regular and expected outcome of their use, as an inherent feature based on the designed capability, kill innocent people.

It is immoral to voluntarily choose to profit from the trafficking in such goods.